Tuesday, 7 April 2015

The Problem with Ratings

It's no secret that I've been trying to figure out this blog ever since I started. The style and format of my reviews have changed here and there as I've gone along and dropped certain elements and added others. But the one thing I've tried to keep consistent since very early on is to include an overall rating of the film (or video game when I eventually review one) to summarize how I feel. I put a reasonable amount of thought into what rating I give a movie, but I never really think when I give one that this is my definitive response to that movie. After all, it's just a number. If when we saw films and entered these new universes to see these incredible stories and the only response we had to that was a number out of ten, it would be a much sadder world. However, I've come to notice while writing my own reviews, and while seeing people feedback on others reviews, that the audience really pays mind only to the numerical rating more often than not. In fact it's not uncommon when checking user ratings for a film to see a very high number of ratings for the maximum or minimum number. This is part of the common misconception that anything below a 5 star rating, or 10 / 10 or whatever, is unworthy. And likewise, anything that doesn't completely engage us deserves the lowest rating it can receive.

Pretty much every reviewer uses a rating system, but what does it mean?

"Kingsman is a fucking 10/10 masterpiece you god damned heretic!"
This year I saw Kingsman: The Secret Service in cinemas. And while I failed to post a review to this blog, I thoroughly enjoyed it. So much so that when entering my rating onto a site (specifically Letterboxd, which I highly recommend to all film fans), I gave it 8 out of 10 on there. What I thought at the time to be a pretty good rating. Only two marks off of perfection, in fact. But still, I encountered one of my friends challenging me on this, telling me how much they enjoyed it and that they thought I did too. But I don't understand. I gave it a high mark, so how were our opinions any different? The reason is that ratings have become devalued in our society. So much so that many people actually mock it (popular YouTube user MrSundayMovies uses only the rankings Best Movie Ever or Worst Movie Ever in his reviews). But I don't want to simply leave it off with either this movie is great or this movie sucks. The reason I use a ten point scale in my reviews instead of a five point scale is to give me more variety when reviewing a film. The entire scale becomes pointless if you don't use the entire thing. Kingsman may have recieved only an 8 out of 10, but that's because in my opinion there were various areas of improvement it could have made that would have escalated it to a 9, or even a 10. And that's not a bad thing! In fact, I'd argue that whenever I'm rating a movie I have the mindset that anything above a 5 is a positive review. That means it's an above average, and ergo good movie. But this isn't how the majority of people view it anymore. When I told somebody that I enjoyed Furious 7 but they saw I gave it a 7 out of 10, they challenged me, asking "I thought you said you enjoyed it? How did it only get a 7?". And the answer to their question is truly the key to it all. 

"6/10?! I'm going to find this 'Oateyboat'. And I'm gonna make him bleed."
The reason I gave Furious 7 a 7 out of 10 can be seen in my review. I wrote my feelings on that movie, explained what I found to be positive and negative and published it online. Pretty much all of my thoughts on it can be found on this very blog, right above the numerical rating. Yet the majority of people don't really pay much heed to the actual review anymore with anyone's reviews. The rating is what's important to them above everything. Which means the majority of movie review readers are pretty much getting the system backwards. A review isn't supposed to be a long winded prelude into the rating. The rating is supposed to be a rough guide to summarize the review and make it easier for comparison. The comparison part is key, because this is also another reason I try to aim for variation with my ratings. There's no point in comparing the ratings if everything is either a 10 out of 10 or a 0 out of 10. By making full use of the entire rating scale in front of you, you make it much easier to compare your own and other's opinions on movies. Again, this isn't supposed to be an exact science that will flawlessly show you the answers; just because I gave both Batman vs Robin and X-Men: Days of Future Past an 8 out of 10, that doesn't mean they're evenly matched films.

"CALL AN AMBULANCE, HELEN! SOMEBODY JUST
GAVE X-MEN AN 8 OUT OF 10 INSTEAD OF A 10!" 
The truth is, there is no perfect, universal way to rank films. Heck, sometimes you may find you disagree with somebody's rating of a product only to actual read the full review and discover your opinions are more alike than you think, and that the reviewer is just a harsher or more generous marker. The only real way we can accurately get our opinions of a movie across is if we actually say them. I know that sounds like bog standard common sense, but it's a lapse in common sense people regularly have when they wonder why the rating system isn't perfect. The entire thing is subjective. And not even just our opinions of the film itself, but how to try to convey that in a numerical form is equally as subjective. Somebody could have the exact same opinion on a film as me, yet I could give it 8 out of 10 and they could give it a 7 out of 10, because it's just so damn opinionated. So next time you see a rating you find to be a bit unfair or maybe too generous, just remember that it's not all about some worthless number slapped onto the end of a review to summarize, but about our actual opinions. Oh yeah, and don't forget that sometimes people have different opinions to you and there's literally not a thing wrong with that. Apologies for the basic common sense editorial, but I felt I needed to get it out there.

I know, Deadpool. I know. 

No comments:

Post a Comment